- Small Business Trends - http://smallbiztrends.com -

Report Finds Small Employers Don’t Use Health Care Credit

Posted By Dawn R. Rivers On June 12, 2012 @ 1:00 pm In Employment | 5 Comments

Did you have a pleasant National Small Business Week? Or perhaps, like most microbusiness owners, you were too busy to notice?

overwhelmed

President Obama issued a proclamation declaring National Small Business Week to take place May 20-26, 2012. Both the House and the Senate passed resolutions acknowledging the occasion and declaring their undying love of small businesses … like they always do. And the Small Business Administration held its own shindig, during which it crowned its Small Business of the Year … like they always do.

For the record, the Small Business of the Year honoree has never been a microbusiness, in spite of the fact that nine out of ten U.S. firms has fewer than five employees.

Make of that what you will.

Meanwhile, while President Obama and Congressional Democrats and Congressional Republicans were all bragging about all the great stuff they’ve been doing or trying to do for small businesses — none of which is likely to be of much use to microbusinesses — the Government Accountability Office (GAO) released a report [1] that is something of a case in point.

The Obama Administration is particularly proud of the small business friendly provisions in the Patient Care and Affordability Act. For example, there is a tax credit available for small employers that pay at least half their low-wage employees’ health insurance premiums (“low-wage” here means earning $11.50 an hour or less).

The idea behind the tax credit is to create an incentive for those small employers to start offering health insurance to their workers, something only 17% of them were doing as of 2009, and to make the premiums more affordable for said small employers.

Senate Small Business Committee Ranking Member Olympia Snowe (R-ME) and House Small Business Committee Chairman Sam Graves (R-MO) were wondering how that tax credit was working out, so they asked the GAO to look into it. The GAO has found that the tax credit might be working out a lot better if small businesses were actually using it.

It turns out that only 170,300 small employers from a pool estimated at between 1.4 million and 4 million eligible firms claimed the tax credit. The cost of the credit, pegged by the Congressional Budget Office at $2 billion in fiscal 2010, was only $480 million.

So, what happened?

It’s very simple and fairly typical of what happens whenever Congress does something to the tax code as a favor to small businesses. The GAO report confirmed that the tax credit is so complicated to figure out that small business owners don’t want to take the time to figure it out. That includes figuring out which of their employees qualifies to be counted as an FTE (full time equivalent) worker, whether they qualified in terms of wages, and which employees could be used for a partial credit or full credit.

This is not the only tax benefit that microbusiness owners don’t use because of the issue of tax complexity. It is estimated that only about one-third of eligible firms use the Business Use of the Home deduction, and only about 9% of qualifying small businesses use the Section 179 business expensing deduction. Complicated rules, computational complexities and a general sense that the tax benefit isn’t worth the hassle is what keeps may microbusinesses from taking full advantage of the tax code.

In addition, and this is also confirmed by the GAO report, it is difficult to incentivize the spending of money that small employers, and especially microbusiness employers, simply don’t have. Before you can qualify for the credit, you have to spend the money. Before you spend the money, you have to have the money.

I never thought this was a difficult concept but they have never seemed to “get” this one in Washington, from what I can see.

As a general matter, microbusiness employers care about their employees. They also know that they are competing for workers with larger companies that have more resources and can offer better benefits. Microbusiness employers would offer health insurance benefits to their employees, without government incentives, if they could afford it.

The fact that most of them don’t is not an indication of negligence or poor personnel management or miserly inclinations on the part of small business owners. It is simply an indication of the fact that their cash flow does not allow them to offer those benefits and a tax benefit that they won’t realize for a year isn’t going to make that money magically materialize in their company bank accounts.

Interestingly, neither Chairman Graves nor Ranking Member Snowe have released statements in response to the GAO’s findings, which were released in mid-May. It is possible that the report did not tell them what they wanted to hear or was otherwise insufficiently damning of President Obama’s health care reform initiative.

However that may be, this much is clear:  whatever the President and Congress intended by way of a small business friendly health care reform law, what they wound up with is every bit as useless for microbusinesses as most of the other small business policy that emerges from Capitol Hill.


Overwhelmed [2] Photo via Shutterstock


Article printed from Small Business Trends: http://smallbiztrends.com

URL to article: http://smallbiztrends.com/2012/06/report-small-employers-dont-use-health-care-credit.html

URLs in this post:

[1] Government Accountability Office (GAO) released a report: http://www.gao.gov/products/GAO-12-549

[2] Overwhelmed: http://www.shutterstock.com/pic-91800845/stock-photo-woman-with-crazed-expression-working-on-income-tax-return-and-household-finances-while-surrounded.html