September 23, 2014

Facebook Ends (Some) Sponsored Stories Amidst Fake Endorsement Lawsuit

Facebook Sponsored Stories

If you blinked you might have missed it. In a recent edition of its “Platform Roadmap” published in Facebook’s development section, the company said it would “sunset” its sponsored stories advertising option.  Or they may only be sunsetting a type of sponsored story.  Like much of the language around Facebook’s ad products, it’s bafflingly confusing and unclear.

But the part we do know, at least, is that sponsored stories that show certain aspects of what other people Like, are being discontinued effective April 9, 2014.

This ad product is not to be confused with “promoted posts” (which are staying).  Promoted posts are when you pay to promote one of your own Facebook update posts.  Those remain unchanged by this announcement.

The sponsored stories at issue here appear to be the ones involving a business paying to turn someone else’s Like activity into an ad.  These involve Likes of a business’s website (“domain sponsored stories”) , and Likes of a business’s app or story in an app (“open graph sponsored stories”).

Say, for instance, that your name is Courtney Cronin and that you “Liked” something on the Jasper’s Market website.  Jasper’s Market could pay to have that action (with your name and face attached) turned into a sponsored story ad.   (See image above).

So why are they being discontinued?  Facebook doesn’t say.  But, sponsored stories have been controversial.

Facebook says these notifications provide sponsors with “social context” showing that users are interacting with the brand. But critics of the sponsored stories feature have said that it gives the impression of an endorsement and should require a user’s consent for use of their image and name.  So in the example of Courtney Cronin, if Courtney happens to be a prominent food critic and writes a popular food blog, it could amount to a valuable endorsement, without paying Courtney anything for the use of her name and likeness.  If you were Courtney, you might not like that.

Suit Alleges Facebook Faked “Likes”

The elimination of sponsored stories may have something to do with a class action suit recently filed against Facebook which seems to connect to the feature.

This lawsuit alleges that Facebook “faked” likes from a Colorado man, Anthony DiTirro, (and perhaps others).  It claims Facebook also featured DiTirro’s photo and name on a sponsored story paid for by USA Today. DiTirro is asking for $750 in damages for himself and restitution for any other users affected.

Conspicuously, the suit was filed the same day Facebook announced it would discontinue the sponsored stories feature, observed Marketing Land.

In its announcement on the official “Platform Roadmap” outlining future Facebook developments, the company seemed to downplay the importance of the sponsored stories feature, explaining:

“Page post and page like ads already automatically have the best social context (likes and comments) added.”

Got that?  It wasn’t very clear to us either.  But one thing that seems clear is that you can no longer create new sponsored stories that involve Liking something on a company’s webpage. And existing ones have to be finished with their runs by April 9th.

The concession may speak volumes. Critics have insisted that Facebook sees its users more like products than customers. But it is their interest that drives activity on the site and their attention advertisers are paying to capture.

We’ll update this story as the facts become clearer.

Image: Facebook

More in: 3 Comments ▼

Shawn Hessinger - Editor


Shawn Hessinger Shawn Hessinger is the Editor for Small Business Trends. He is a journalist and social media networker with more than a decade of experience in the traditional newspaper business before moving to the digital world. He was the former community manager of BizSugar and the former community editor at AllAnalytics, a site dedicated to professionals in the business intelligence and analytics community.

3 Reactions

  1. I think it is just right. Likes should be made as authentic as possible. Faking likes to support an advertising platform is just absurd. They have all the right to sue Facebook for doing this to them. After all, this may create a whole new image that is not entirely who the person is talking about.

  2. I have seen this happening with Facebook so much lately; they are just shooting themselves in the foot every chance they get and I don’t understand why.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>



Compare your business to the industry - Try our new tool