Case Study: Moving a Business Blog from Blogger to WordPress


Several of you have emailed me with questions about why I moved Small Business Trends over to its new home here and made the switch to WordPress software. So I thought I would take a few minutes to describe exactly what led up to the move.

Starting with Blogger

Making the move was a big decision. This Small Business Trends site has become a more central part of my business than I could have imagined when I first started banging out blog posts on my old Dell laptop over two years ago.

Small Business Trends started out using Blogger software. In the summer of 2003 when I was first experimenting with blogging, Blogger was one of the better options. It was simple to set up and use. Both the software and hosting were free. And with Blogger having been acquired by Google earlier that year, my business intuition told me it might be an advantage for getting the site indexed and ranked in Google. Blogger seemed like a deal I could not refuse.

Rapid Growth

Over the next two years, the site grew — and the limitations of the free Blogger site started to surface. I realized we needed extra pages so that information would be available even after it cycled off the home page. So I started tacking on extra pages at another domain I had registered, smallbiztrends.com, in order to provide better ways for readers to find information. I created pages for the newsletter, the Experts Directory, and so on.

Escalating Costs

I also started adding on custom features, such as the Free Find service in order to provide a decent way to search the site — something Blogger lacked. Comments and trackbacks (i.e., a kind of display of inbound links) through Haloscan came next.

What a hodgepodge! Small Business Trends became a site that spanned two different blogs, together with extra pages hosted at a third URL. And it had a slew of extra services I was paying for, so the “free” part turned out not to be free in the end.

Inefficient to Maintain

It became harder and harder to maintain the site, too. The extra pages I added were built using Dreamweaver MX, without any content management system. Updating those pages was a manual process. It also took extra time to manage all the outside services that were adding functionality to the site.

Even changing the blogroll links and changing the template for the blog portion of the site became increasingly laborious, as anyone who has used Blogger software knows. Blogger is great for a simple blog where you rarely change the template. If all you want to do is set up a blog quickly and post your thoughts now and then to it, Blogger is easy-peesy and I highly recommend it. However, if you plan to keep the site active and vibrant by changing links, swapping out announcements and ads, running polls and surveys, and so on, Blogger blogs are not efficient. To change the template you need to know a good deal of HTML, which for me was not a problem, but wading through hundreds of lines of HTML every time you need to change a blogroll link is just not an efficient business process.

Each task was a small thing, but together they added up to a mountain of small things. For a site as active as this one, maintenance started to take noticeable time.

Lacked Own Domain

The lack of a dedicated domain address was another drawback. Previously this site was hosted at a subdomain of blogspot.com, along with countless other blogs. Without your own domain you have no control over the site at the server level. If the site is not performing well, you have no ability to fix it. You can only email Blogger Support. As helpful as Support tried to be, remember that Small Business Trends was just one of millions of accounts. Blogger Support was not likely to have the same level of urgency to fix my problems, as I would have.

Not having a dedicated domain was a drawback in another sense. Some prospective advertisers and advertising networks begged off due to policies that prohibit placing advertising in sites with shared or free domains. That limited the earning potential from this site. My business plan requires that this site pay its own way, and not be a drain on cash flow.

Poor Navigation

Finally, there was the poor navigation scheme. Blogs are great for easy and fast reading of current posts. But blog navigation in general leaves a lot to be desired. Your average blog’s navigation is primitive — that is the only way I can describe it.

Usually there is a single page template. There is a tendency to cram as much navigation (i.e., links) on that single template as possible.

On top of that, in Blogger there are no “categories” for easy searching of archives. That leads to home page overload — the tendency to make the home page really long, out of fear that the reader may never find older posts.

That was the problem with the old home page of Small Business Trends. It got too long. At times it had 200+ outbound links on it. The first design was hard-coded with tables, which is good for cross-browser compatibility, but that made the HTML code a mile long. It was slow to load and cumbersome to read. That led to yet another problem I began to notice: Google and the blog search engines like Technorati had trouble picking up all the links on the page. They just choked on that page!

The Need for Change

By the summer of 2005 it was obvious that the site needed changes, so that it would function better and be easier to maintain. The site needed a design refresh, too, in order to bring it up to 2006 standards. So I made the decision to redesign the look, move to WordPress software, and transition everything to the smallbiztrends.com domain — all at one time.

However, making the decision to move, and actually getting it done are two different things. You see, the more time that passes, the harder a move becomes.

In Small Business Trends’ case, traffic had grown. By the summer of 2005, the site had thousands of incoming links, not only from blogs but from key business websites. It also achieved a Google PageRank of 7. The mere thought of disrupting all of that was disheartening.

In short, I had a dilemma not unlike what many small businesses face as they grow:

    (1) The infrastructure was not scalable. Growth only made the problems worse. The bigger the site became, the more laborious and expensive it was to maintain.
    (2) The longer we waited, the harder it became to change the status quo. The site was growing larger by the day, so there were more pages to migrate over. And, clearly, making changes to the site would disrupt some of the forward momentum that was growing daily, including traffic, link counts and Page Rank. The more momentum and traffic the site built up, the more disruption a site move would entail.

In the end I knew we would have to take a slight detour from our forward momentum, and move the site. If we did not move, the site’s limitations would stunt its future growth potential. But by moving the site, Small Business Trends would quickly recover and move forward faster and more efficiently, with lower operating costs.

Budget and Team

I set a budget for hiring skilled outside help for the move. Even though WordPress is open source software and is free, my requirements included a custom design and a number of special features. And I wanted the old site migrated over properly, so that all the old archives would be in one place — searchable and usable by readers. WordPress blogs need to be set up by someone who knows what they are doing. I needed to hire skilled help.

So I found a talented design firm that specializes in blogs — Blogudio — and got to know Eric Sagalyn, the owner. I hired him — and I have been thrilled with his firm’s work.

I also needed someone to help migrate my existing RSS feeds. By this time I had a half dozen different feeds (long story for another day) and subscribers numbered in the mid four figures. I did some blog surfing, and found a very talented young man, Tom Sherman, to sort out my RSS situation and re-direct as many of my old RSS formats as possible to the new RSS feeds, so that we could minimize the disruption to readers. We did manage to avoid a lot of disruption — again I was thrilled with his work.

I also have to acknowledge Stuart Watson, CEO of SyndicateIQ, a service I use to understand the readership of my RSS feeds better. Stuart and his team at SyndicateIQ worked to help migrate the RSS feeds, too.

Even though Small Business Trends is a sole proprietorship company, we had a virtual team for this project assembled entirely through the Internet. The four of us are spread out across the United States. None of us have ever actually met in person. But it worked out well through email, cell phone and instant messenger.

The Move

I have run Internet websites since 1999. As I have learned over the years, moving a site like this with nearly 800 pages always takes more time than expected. And unforeseen issues always pop up, especially when the business is a small one of the size of Small Business Trends where we have few hands to devote to technical issues in the first place.

As of this writing six days later I am still engaged in minor clean-up issues with the site. (I have to fit in the site work with other work, remember.) However, overall I judge the move a success.

For anyone still using Blogger for a business blog, I hope this post has given you helpful insights for the future direction of your blog, and the decisions you may be faced with. For anyone contemplating a blog who has not started one yet, perhaps this will help you avoid mistakes.

More in: 24 Comments ▼

Anita Campbell - CEO


Anita Campbell Anita Campbell is the Founder and Publisher of Small Business Trends and has been following trends in small businesses since 2003. She is the owner of BizSugar, a social media site for small businesses, and also serves as CEO of TweakYourBiz.com.

24 Reactions

  1. Thanks for filling us in, Anita, and congrats again on the big move!

    One last question, if you please….

    Why WordPress over the other options?

    Stacy

  2. Anita Campbell

    Thanks Stacy.

    Of course, you were one of the people who emailed me asking why I made the move. I will answer the question “Why WordPress?” in the next post I write on this subject.

    🙂

    Anita

  3. Anita,

    Thank you for this well written post. I am thinking of leaving Blogger and I was wondering how to go about it. I will continue to follow up on your reply to explain why you chose World Press.

  4. Thank you so much for this excellent post as you have helped me make my decision on moving to a more professional blog. Thanks for the help and can’t wait to read more post.

  5. My main concern is that you can’t guarantee every page of your website will be included in the SERPs. Considering I’m constantly adding new products to my company’s website, I need to be sure that customers can find them as soon as possible.http://www.seoptimizerz.com

  6. That’s it. After reading this, I have finally made the decision to jump to WP before it’s too late. Have purchased a domain name and found a host already but was thinking of still using my blogger template. With this however, it’s definite. It will be WP for me from now on.

    Thanks for this valuable info. Will share with you my “moving” experience soon.

    From the tuna capital of the Phils., hello.

  7. Very helpful info. I’m glad I found it before having more time vested in Blogger. I’m moving my business blog to WP today.

    Thanks, Michael

  8. hi michael,

    Thanks for the write with I guess even after 3 years later people would be reading this post. I am in the mist of conveting the rest of my blogger blogs to wordpress blog. I also found it easy to monetise from affiliate networks and adsense from wordpress blogging.

    have a nice day!

  9. Blogger can do everything you had a problem with now and is completely free. WordPress you have to pay for extras.

  10. You have to pay for extras?

    Like what? I havent seen anyhting like that, there seems to be a plethora of plug ins etc

  11. Hi Anita,

    I’m the founder/co-developer of a membership plugin for WordPress.

    This is precisely the reason we tell people to get away from Blogger. In fact, we even tell them to get away from hosted blogs at WordPress.com (the hosted version of wordpress), because wordpress.com won’t let you upload your own custom plugins which can really help you monetize your blog), or publish advertisements or affiliate inks.

    [sidebar]How can we work with you to promote our product? Would you/your company be willing to become an affiliate of ours? Or would we have to go through your ad channel?[/sidebar]

    Thanks!

    – Ravi Jayagopal

  1. Pingback:

    Brewed Fresh Daily » Small Business Trends

  2. Pingback: OPTIMUSCRIME.COM » Blog Archive » “I, For One, Welcome Our New Google Overlords…”

  3. Pingback:

    jotsheet

  4. Pingback: The Next Faze of Evolution » Blog Archive » Move from Blogger

  5. Pingback:

    Curly Tree Money Blog: From Employee To Entrepreneur

  6. Pingback: romantika.name - » Why WordPress

  7. Pingback: Case Study: Moving a Business Blog from Blogger to WordPress « Youngblood PR & Marketing

  8. Pingback: morph8 » Transfer complete!

  9. Pingback:

    Why WordPress Is The Only Blogging Platform I’d Recommend

  10. Pingback:

    » Using Wordpress Instead of Blogger

  11. Pingback:

    Attention to All Blog Readers @ zmlee™ « zmlee™

  12. Pingback: Blogger Only Goes So Far | website design | usability and accessibility | social media | online marketing | fog of eternity

  13. Pingback:

    Flytta från Blogger till Wordpress | Andreas Karman

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*