When it comes to what your employees want, too many small business owners are in denial. At least, that’s the finding of a new study by MetLife, which polled small business owners and employees and found that while employee loyalty has dropped steadily since 2008, employers mistakenly believe it’s on the rise.
More than one-third of the work force (36 percent) hopes to find a new job soon, and among younger employees (Gen X and Gen Y), that number hits 42 percent.
If you’re looking to replace lost workers, be aware that benefits were also an important factor in attracting younger workers—even more so than in attracting Boomer-age workers.
One reason younger workers are more likely to be influenced by benefits is because they’re having a harder time financially, with 50 percent saying they’re more reliant on employee benefits for financial security than they were in the past.
However, that’s not to say Boomers are carefree. More than half of employees in all age groups are worried about making ends meet, paying for health insurance and paying down debt.
Employers are also in the dark about what benefits contribute most to employee loyalty. Asked what benefits were key drivers of loyalty, more than half (52 percent) of employees named retirement benefits, 44 percent said nonmedical insurance benefits (such as life insurance) and 38 percent want to have a choice of benefits.
While employers in the survey were well aware of the importance of benefits, 65 percent report it has become more difficult to pay for them.
The good news for cost-conscious employers: Two-thirds of younger workers and more than half of Boomers say they’d rather pay for more of the cost of their benefits than lose them altogether.
Give Employees What They Want
The title of the study, Are You Listening? offers a clue. Start by asking your employees what kinds of benefits they care about most. You may find, based on the age group of most of your employees, that the results are not what you expected.
Figure out what kinds of benefits you can offer. Is there something that would make you a more desirable employer because none of your competitors offer it? Conversely, is there some type of benefit that’s considered “essential” or basic in your industry or your area?
Figure out what you can afford and how much your employees are willing to pay. If something that employees care about deeply is out of your price range, can they contribute part (or all) of the cost?
You might be surprised: MetLife found that more than one-third of employees were interested in having access to disability coverage, life insurance, dental insurance and vision insurance—even if they had to pay 100 percent of the cost.
Letting employees know what you offer and how much it costs is key to building loyalty. Be transparent about the cost of policies and how much of the tab you are picking up. Employees often underestimate these costs, and showing them the reality will make the benefits more valuable to them and build loyalty.
Don’t “set and forget” your benefits. Do an annual checkup to ask employees what benefits they used, what they care about and what they don’t care about. Also talk to your insurance agent(s) each year to assess whether you have adequate coverage, what you can drop (and add) and ways to lower your bill.
Going forward, the trend toward employees contributing more for coverage won’t end anytime soon. As the war for talent heats up, having employees chip in for their benefits will make it easier for small business owners to win at least part of the battle.
Listening Photo via Shutterstock
Job seekers are not very good at calculating the total value of compensation, so it’s hard to compare different offers apples-to-apples.
The assumption that we need to provide benefits is a reflection of Industrial Age thinking. Benefits are not necessary in the modern work place, and are more likely to create a less productive environment full of people who want to be taken care of.
Our company is very proud to offer no benefits, no vacation time, no work hours, no sick time, and no 401k. We hire adults how are required to get those things for themselves. Our company has grown by 60-90% per year the last four years and we have people asking if they can come to work for us.
Why? Because we expect everyone to be adults and own things, self-manage (we don’t have managers) and produce results in order to get paid. We are a results-based culture, not a time-based culture (a hallmark of an Industrial Age company).
Benefits are a leftover from the Industrial Age, as is the traditional concept of “employees” and “managers”. These were bad ideas when Frederick Winslow Taylor and his buddies invented them in the late 19th century, and they’re worse ideas today.
People are motivated to make meaning, not just money. Offer them both and they will knock down the doors to come work with (not for) you.
Most traditional health benefit programs create an ever growing business expense. Premiums keep rising, while coverage shrinks. The Affordable Care Act is likely to exacerbate this trend.
Younger employees in particular gravitate to employee paid options. Employers can meet worker needs by being open and supportive of voluntary plans.