SEO Pro Gets Jail Time for “Negative Review” Extortion

negative review

A 53-year-old SEO pro will spend more than three years in prison for attempting to extort money from a Dallas firm.

William Stanley (a.k.a  William Laurence, Bill Stanley, William Davis, William Harris, and William L. Stanley) has been sentenced to 37 months in prison after threatening to write negative reviews and comments about the company unless paid.

The court has also ordered that Stanley pay $174,888 in restitution to a dozen victims.

In an official release, the United States Attorney’s Office, Northern District of Texas said Stanley had attempted to extort money from Dallas-based mergers and acquisition firms Generational Equity.

Officials say Stanley was originally contracted by the firm for SEO services and reputation management. The company then tried to fire Stanley when it was discovered he had also created sites aimed at damaging the company’s reputation by attempting to link it to a scam.

Stanley then extorted an additional $80,000 from Generational Equity to sever his contractual relationship with the company and give its officials access to the fraudulent websites.

Small Business Deals

He also sent emails and made phone calls under the aliases of William Davis and William Laurence threatening negative reviews damaging the company’s reputation and was paid another $29,556.

Stanley’s sister, Lynn Faust (a.k.a. Lynn Michaels) was indicted in 2014 and faces a maximum of three years in prison and a $250,000 fine for assisting in her brother’s criminal activities.

Positive and negative reviews have become big business online both as a way to promote new products and services and to negate bad reviews from others.

In 2013, New York Attorney General Eric T. Schneiderman announced a deal with 19 businesses agreeing to pay $350,000 in fines following an investigation by Schneiderman’s office.

The attorney general’s office said the businesses had been involved in recruiting and hiring freelancers to write fake reviews on a number of review sites including Yelp.

As recently as October 2015, Amazon filed suit against 1,114 users. The company identified the individuals during an investigation in which Amazon representatives attempted to buy fake reviews from gig site Fiverr.

Even after the suit was filed, ads for both positive and negative reviews could still be found on Fiverr.

Meanwhile some members of the SEO community didn’t appreciate the characterization of Stanley as primarily an SEO professional. They didn’t appreciate being associated with what many consider an unethical way of gaining attention online.

Image: U.S. District Court, Northern District of Texas, via 1 Comment ▼

Lisa Froelings Lisa is a Staff Writer for Small Business Trends focusing on marketing technology, productivity and general small business news. She has a background in business and productivity consulting including experience in human resources working for a major retailer before deciding to build her own business.

One Reaction
  1. Don’t let one man’s sins put a black mark on the entire SEO industry. There are plenty of good ones out there, but you need to do your due diligence to ensure you get a good one.