8 Tips For Creating a Quality Loyalty Program

creating a quality loyalty program

In the fiercely competitive business landscape, creating a loyalty program that resonates with customers and encourages repeat business is more crucial than ever. A well-crafted loyalty program not only rewards customers but also fosters a deeper connection with your brand, turning occasional buyers into lifelong advocates. But what makes a loyalty program truly stand out and keep customers coming back for more? Below, leaders from the Young Entrepreneur Council (YEC) share their invaluable insights on this very question:

“What’s one tip you have for creating a quality loyalty program that will keep customers coming back for more? Why?”

Their responses shed light on the essential elements of successful loyalty programs, from personalized rewards to leveraging technology for enhanced customer experiences.

1. Flexible Rewards

“One tip for creating a quality loyalty program that will keep customers coming back for more is providing flexible rewards. Allowing customers to choose from a variety of different perks will motivate users to come back as it increases the curiosity of the customer to see what can be redeemed each time.” ~ Jordan Edelson, Appetizer Mobile

2. Consider Customer Preferences

“Personalize rewards and experiences based on customer preferences and behaviors. Customizing communication offers, and rewards can make customers feel valued and understood, increasing engagement and loyalty to your brand. Tailored rewards ensure relevance, enhancing the perceived value of the program and encouraging repeat business.” ~ Kristin Kimberly Marquet, Marquet Media

3. Implement Multiple Tiers

“You can create a quality loyalty program by implementing a multi-tiered loyalty program. In this program, you can add different levels and incentivize customers to progress and engage more with your brand. Each tier can offer escalating benefits, creating a sense of achievement and encouraging customers to stay loyal to reach higher levels.” ~ Thomas Griffin, OptinMonster

4. Surprise Customers

“Occasionally surprise your customers with unexpected rewards or personalized offers. This element of surprise creates excitement and positively influences the customer experience. It also demonstrates that you value and appreciate their loyalty. It also motivates them to come back again.” ~ Andrew Munro, AffiliateWP

5. Offer Real Rewards

“Make customers feel like they actually benefit from a loyalty program. Too many loyalty programs simply offer minor rewards after many transactions. However, brands like Starbucks reward customers frequently with free drinks or significant discounts. Make sure customers get real rewards often and they’ll find it more cost-effective to buy from your repeatedly.” ~ Blair Williams, MemberPress

6. Incorporate Feedback

“Loyalty programs shouldn’t always be about special offers and discounts. In addition to that, use your loyalty programs to ask your customers for their input on how you can improve your solutions. This shows that you care and that their feedback means a lot to you. Knowing that their opinions matter, your customers keep coming back to you for more and are less likely to switch to alternatives.” ~ Chris Klosowski, Easy Digital Downloads

7. Form Loyalty Program Partnerships

“You can dramatically boost sales and engagement by working with another business and forming a loyalty program partnership. Essentially, this means people can earn points for your site by shopping on a partner’s website and vice versa. This is an excellent way to improve awareness and convince people to visit your site who otherwise might not know your brand exists.” ~ Daman Jeet Singh, FunnelKit

8. Shower Customers with Value

“I think it’s important to recognize your customers and make them feel special. You could do this by giving them points for actions they take, by assigning them to tiers that sound exclusive, and my showering them with value via content and gifts. When customers feel like they’re getting more from you than your competition, they’ll always return to you.” ~ Syed Balkhi, WPBeginner

Image: Envato Elements

The Young Entrepreneur Council The Young Entrepreneur Council (YEC) is an invite-only organization comprised of the world's most promising young entrepreneurs. In partnership with Citi, YEC recently launched StartupCollective, a free virtual mentorship program that helps millions of entrepreneurs start and grow businesses.